The haircuts that came last because most of them were cut in beauty salons
Showing the misleading chart
A strategy slide we drew from the 2022 Economic Census ranks what Americans spent on looking good and puts haircuts dead last, at $1.7 billion, with nails nearly seven times bigger. The rows are kinds of shop, not kinds of service: “Haircuts” is the revenue of 7,025 barber shops. Counted by service, across every seller with paid staff, hair care was the biggest line at $21.7 billion against nails’ $12.7 billion, and haircuts and styling on their own came within a whisker of nails.
01The claim
Haircuts come dead last in what Americans spend on looking good: $1.7 billion in 2022, behind even diet plans, while nails took nearly seven times as much.
02The trick
The shop named after haircuts sells only a small share of them. The 2022 Economic Census counts by establishment: each shop gets one industry code for its main line of business, and every dollar it takes is filed under that code. The slide’s five rows are those codes with friendlier names, and their revenue adds up correctly to the census’s $54.8 billion for personal-care businesses. “Haircuts” is NAICS 812111, barber shops: the $1.66 billion taken by 7,025 barber shops with paid staff. It leaves out every haircut sold anywhere else. The row the slide called “Beauty & makeup” is 812112, beauty salons, 83,392 of them, and 72% of their $25.7 billion was hair care; they sold $9.5 billion of haircuts and styling alone, against the barber shops’ $1.5 billion. Among businesses with paid staff, about seven in eight haircut-and-styling dollars went to shops other than barber shops. “Spa, tattoos & body treatments” is 812199, other personal care services, and “Diet & weight loss” is 812191, diet and weight reducing centers. So the chart answers “which kind of shop took the most money?” under labels that ask “which service did people buy?”, and the two come apart wherever one kind of shop sells another kind’s service. The standfirst’s “most complete count there is” adds a second, quieter gap: the Economic Census covers only businesses with employees, and barbering is mostly one-person businesses, so the barber row loses more to that rule than any other on the slide. (Clip & Co., its offsite and its plan to rebadge the clippers as cuticle trimmers are invented for this demonstration; the revenue figures come from the Census Bureau.)
03The fix
The redraw uses the census’s other table. Besides filing each shop under one industry, the Economic Census asks it what it sold, and publishes the answers as product lines across every kind of seller. Counted that way, hair care services came to $21.7 billion in 2022: $18.6 billion sold by beauty salons, $1.6 billion by barber shops and $1.6 billion by everyone else. That is the biggest service line in personal care, ahead of nail care at $12.7 billion, about 1.7 to 1. On haircuts alone the honest answer is closer. The narrowest line, haircut and styling services, leaves out colour, perms and treatments, and came to at least $11.3 billion (beauty salons $9.5 billion, barber shops $1.5 billion, other personal-care shops $0.4 billion; the line is not broken out for other sellers, which sold $1.6 billion of hair care of every kind, so the most it can be is about $12.5 billion). Nails still edge haircuts, by a whisker rather than the slide’s 6.8 to 1. The “Nails” bar barely moves, from $11.4 billion to $12.7 billion, because nail salons and nail care line up: those salons sold $11.1 billion of the $12.7 billion, and 98% of what they sold was nail care. That is the test for reading an industry row as a product: the label is only safe where the shop and the service coincide. Both charts share one limit, and it falls hardest on barbers. The Economic Census covers businesses with paid employees; one-person businesses are counted separately, from tax records, as nonemployers. In 2022, 137,372 barber businesses without employees reported $4.2 billion of receipts, 72% of all barber-shop receipts, against about half for beauty salons ($24.3 billion) and nail salons ($11.7 billion). There is no service split for them, so they are in neither chart. The service lines also don’t add up to $54.8 billion, because personal-care shops sell shampoo and rent out chairs too, and some services are sold by spas, hotels and clinics outside personal care. A chart about shops should say “barber shops” on the bar and “employer businesses” in the subtitle. A chart about what people buy needs the products-by-industry table, with the service named on the axis.