MisleadingCharts
Back to the gallery

The 1920s that rated 8.1 on 13 of their 22,084 films

Showing the misleading chart

1 star · count refreshes daily

A film-club newsletter we drew ranks every decade of cinema by average IMDb rating and finds that movies peaked before they learned to talk: 8.1 for the 1920s, sliding to 6.6 for the 2010s. The chart only counts films with 25,000+ votes, and a 1920s film has to stay famous for a century to get there. Thirteen did, against 2,253 from the 2010s. Compare like with like, each decade’s 13 most-voted films, and the 1920s come eighth of ten.

01The claim

Films have got steadily worse since the 1920s: the silent era is the best-rated decade in cinema, and the average has fallen 1.5 stars since the talkies arrived.

02The trick

Every bar is a true average of real IMDb ratings, on an honest zero-based axis. The trick is in the fine print: only films with 25,000 or more votes are counted. That sounds like a sensible way to ignore obscure titles with a handful of ratings, but it is a far higher bar for an old film than a new one. Votes come from people watching the film now, so a 1920s film only collects 25,000 of them if it is still being watched a century later, which means it has to be one of the decade’s acknowledged classics. Of the 22,084 1920s feature films IMDb lists, 13 cleared the bar: Metropolis, The General, The Gold Rush, Nosferatu and nine more of the same calibre, every one rated 7.8 or better. A recent hit can clear the same bar within a year of release, so 2,253 films from the 2010s made it, about one in 75 of those IMDb lists, against one in 1,699 for the 1920s. The chart is comparing the surviving canon of the past with a broad sample of the present, and the canon wins. The slide across the decades tracks how easy the bar was to clear: it gets easier with almost every decade until the 2000s, and the bars stop falling in the 2010s, the one decade where the cut tightens again because IMDb lists so many more recent titles. (We drew this newsletter and its film club ourselves, as a demonstration; the ratings are IMDb’s.)

03The fix

The redraw compares like with like: the same number of films from every decade, each decade’s 13 most-voted. For the 1920s that is the same 13 films, at 8.08. Every other decade gets its own 13 best-remembered, and the 1920s come eighth of ten, ahead of only the 1930s (8.04) and 1940s (8.00), and behind every decade since 1950, from 8.25 for the 1960s to 8.67 for the 1990s; the 2010s score 8.31. The 13 survivors were never typical of their decade: of the 22,084 1920s feature films IMDb lists, only 4,156 have a rating at all, and those other 4,143 average 5.98, with 1,680 below 6. Plenty of forgettable films were made then too; most have simply stopped being watched, and many no longer exist. A table beside the chart shows that the slope is a setting, not a finding. Every film above 25,000 votes gives a 1.48-star fall from the 1920s to the 2010s; above 1,000 votes, 0.95; above 100, 0.74; and with every rated film counted the 2010s come out 0.24 ahead. None of those floors is neutral, either: the lowest mixes in new films rated by a few dozen fans and many more documentaries, and IMDb voters are a self-selected crowd. No version of this chart measures how good each decade’s films really were. The narrower lesson travels: when a chart compares old and new things on a measure that piles up with attention (votes, reviews, citations, downloads), ask what share of each period cleared the cut. If it is one in 1,699 for one bar and one in 75 for another, the bars are not measuring the same thing.